Turning Point USA's Professor Watchlist of college instructors, 2016-2025
In November 2016 Kirk's Turning Point USA launched Professor Watchlist, a public site naming college instructors it accused of leftist bias and inviting students to submit tips. Academic groups said it threatened academic freedom and could chill teaching. Kirk called it an awareness tool, not a blacklist. In 2025, outlets reported that some listed professors had received threats.
Editorial timeline of public reporting, not a legal finding.
- Turning Point USA launches Professor Watchlist - Inside Higher Ed and Snopes reported that Turning Point USA launched ProfessorWatchList.org to "expose and document" professors it said discriminate against conservative students and "advance leftist propaganda in the classroom." Kirk promoted it on X: "Crazy radical professor at your school? ... Submit your professors on the site!" The New York Times reported the site named nearly 200 professors at launch. New website seeks to register professors accused of liberal bias and 'anti-American values'
- Academic groups call the list a threat to academic freedom - The New York Times reported that the site was criticized as a threat to academic freedom. Inside Higher Ed quoted the American Association of University Professors, which said outside monitoring of classroom speech risks distortion and is likely to have a chilling effect, and noted that some listed professors said their entries were inaccurate. New website seeks to register professors accused of liberal bias and 'anti-American values'
- Notre Dame faculty ask to be added in protest - The Washington Post and NPR reported that more than 100 University of Notre Dame faculty signed an open letter asking Professor Watchlist to add their names in solidarity with listed colleagues, writing that the list's purpose appeared to be "to shame and silence faculty." The Washington Post later reported that more than 1,500 academics had asked to join. 'The sort of company we wish to keep': More than 1,500 academics ask to join controversial 'Professor Watchlist'
- Listed professors report threats; Kirk had called it an awareness tool - WBEZ reported nearly 50 Illinois instructors on the list, some of whom described hateful emails and rape or death threats that intensified after Kirk was killed in September 2025. NBC News said the list had grown past 300 names and recalled Kirk's 2018 defense: "It's not 'Professor Blacklist'... We're not calling for the termination of these professors." The Guardian cited academics' fears. Illinois professors face threats after landing on Charlie Kirk group watch list