حامد کاشانی 🇮🇷 (@hamedkashani__)
Public criticism timeline and community reputation for this profile on RepIndex. Ratings are community votes, not verified facts.
هر چه گفتیم جز حکایت دوست / در همه عمر از آن پشیمانیم. تنها حساب رسمی بنده، حامد کاشانی اینجا است. https://t.co/oTUXQ1cq3a
Score: 0/100 · 1 votes · Neutral
حامد کاشانی 🇮🇷 on RepIndex: community score 0/100 from 1 votes (Neutral). Top negative reasons: Government Connections (1). These figures are community votes, not verified facts.
Public criticisms
Editorial timeline of public reporting, not a legal finding.
Reported TV remarks on tawhid and wilayah
Outlets reported that on Channel 3's Ramadan 2020 pre-dawn show, Hamed Kashani called love of Ali the principle of religion and framed tawhid without wilayah as an illusion; critics called it religious distortion, and he clarified the next night.
- Reported remarks on Channel 3 Mah Man show - YJC and Rouydad24 reported that on Channel 3's pre-dawn Ramadan 2020 show Mah Man, Hamed Kashani called love of Imam Ali the principle of religion and described tawhid without accepting wilayah as an illusion; that line later circulated in clipped clips. توضیحات حجت‌الاسلام کاشانی درباره اظهاراتش در برنامه «ماه من»
- Critical backlash and clipped clips online - Rouydad24 and HarfeTaze reported that after the broadcast, clipped clips titled along the lines of tawhid is nothing but an illusion circulated online; critics called the remarks a distortion of religious issues in new language, while supporters said the line was taken out of context. ماجرای سخنان تقطیع شده حجت الاسلام کاشانی: توحید توهمی بیش نیست
- Reported clarification after the backlash - YJC reported on 10 May 2020 that Kashani replied his phrase targeted incomplete, self-made tawhid not reached through prophets and Imams, not the dismissal of tawhid itself, and framed the line as defending tawhid's greatness. Some commenters in the same coverage still called it a justification rather than an apology. توضیحات حجت‌الاسلام کاشانی درباره اظهاراتش در برنامه «ماه من»
- Rouydad24 revisits the 2020 TV row - On 2 Dec 2025, during Ardestani-debate coverage, Rouydad24 revisited the reported 2020 line that tawhid without wilayah is an illusion, noting critics called it religious distortion while supporters said clips were cut. Persian Wikipedia also records the same controversy. حامد کاشانی که می‌گوید «توحید توهم است» کیست؟
Namusi framing and Wahhabi label in Fatima debate
BBC Persian and other outlets reported that in the 30 Nov 2025 debate with Soleimani Ardestani, Kashani called Fatima's martyrdom namusi for him and said the opponent likely played into Wahhabi networks; critics said that framing shrinks calm scholarly debate.
- Live Azad debate; reported namusi closing line - BBC Persian and Kashani's site reported the 30 Nov 2025 live Azad debate with Abdolrahim Soleimani Ardestani on Fatima's suffering and martyrdom. Kashani closed by saying Fatima's martyrdom is namusi for me and likened the opponent's wording to Wahhabi-network literature. از حجره تا هشتگ؛ چرا مناظره اردستانی و کاشانی «ناموسی» شد؟
- BBC analysis; critics of namusi framing and media camps - BBC Persian on 5 Dec 2025 reported critics saying the namusi framing quickly brands dissent as sacrilege and shrinks calm debate. The same piece noted Fars, Tasnim, and Kayhan's pro-Kashani line; Fars also published a supportive debate analysis. از حجره تا هشتگ؛ چرا مناظره اردستانی و کاشانی «ناموسی» شد؟
- BBC reports protesters entering Ardestani's office - BBC Persian reported that after the debate a video showed protesters entering Soleimani Ardestani's office during a livestream with shouted threats; many likened it to pressure-group tactics. The same report noted sharp clerical and party reactions around the row. از حجره تا هشتگ؛ چرا مناظره اردستانی و کاشانی «ناموسی» شد؟
- Tasnim follow-up on social fallout of public debate - Tasnim on 8 Dec 2025, while praising Kashani's argumentation, wrote that airing this sensitive dispute on a high-emotion media stage was unnecessary and that the aftermath brought emotional reactions and polarization - echoing critics' concern that namusi framing shrinks debate space. پیروزی مطلق حامد کاشانی در مناظر‌ه‌ای که به این شکل ضرورتی نداشت
Top negative reasons
- Government Connections (1)