Critics say he smeared jailed monarchist activist Shakila Monfared
Zand has written that the X account of Shakila Monfared, a monarchist political prisoner jailed since 2021, at times followed her interrogators' orders and that she lied about him. Monarchist critics have cited those posts against him for years. He says she is a victim but the account's past conduct cannot be hidden.
Editorial timeline of public reporting, not a legal finding.
- Monfared jailed over monarchist activism - The Campaign for the Defense of Political and Civil Prisoners reported that Monfared, first arrested in August 2020, was re-arrested on January 20, 2021 and sentenced to six years for "propaganda against the system" and "insulting Islamic sanctities", later reduced to four years and two months. Further cases were opened against her while in prison. شکیلا منفرد، فعال مدنی، به هفت سال و هفت ماه حبس و ۱۰ ضربه شلاق محکوم شد
- Says her account at times followed security orders - Replying to analyst Saeed Ghasseminejad, who had defended Monfared, Zand wrote in a post seen about 96,000 times that when screenshots of her "smears and lies" against activists surfaced, she would say her account had been with her interrogators. He wrote that at times "her account or she herself" followed the orders of security bodies, and that she had falsely said he threatened her. He added that "there is no doubt she is a victim" and said he hoped she would be released. Sharagim Zand on Shakila Monfared and Saeed Ghasseminejad
- New prison sentences for Monfared - VOA Persian reported that Monfared's lawyer said a new case opened while she was in prison ended in a total of seven years and seven months and 10 lashes, after an earlier in-prison case brought 15 months, internal exile and a ban on smartphones. پروندهسازی جدید علیه شکیلا منفرد، زندانی سیاسی
- "Do you defend interrogators too?" - Replying to a critic on X, Zand wrote: "Shakila herself admitted her account was often not in her own hands. Do you defend interrogators too?" Sharagim Zand reply about Shakila Monfared
- Monarchist users single him out on her birthday - On Monfared's birthday, a monarchist account posted that neither her courage nor the "baseness" of Zand and others who it said had labeled her a security agent and built a case against her would be forgotten. The post drew about 130 likes and was reposted widely by other accounts. Monarchist post on Shakila Monfared's birthday
- Critic accuses him of a "Shakilagate" campaign - The same account alleged that Zand had once used the hashtag #Shakilagate to accuse Monfared of collaborating with the security services, and called him a "security piece". The post drew about 370 likes. RepIndex could not find the hashtag in his posts through X search, and in November 2026 Zand called a separate accusation that he aided the security services "baseless". Critic post on Zand and #Shakilagate